Mostrando entradas con la etiqueta evolution. Mostrar todas las entradas
Mostrando entradas con la etiqueta evolution. Mostrar todas las entradas

domingo, 30 de septiembre de 2012

Natural designs exceed rational designs and rational understanding



This is my response to someone somewhere:



Whoever said that, does not know what he says:



"There are great differences between evolutionary designs and rational design, rational designs are, well, rational, but

evolutionary designs are idiotic. Mother Nature (Evolution) is a slow and stupid tinkerer, it had over 3 billion years to work on the problem but it couldn't even come up with a macroscopic part that could rotate in 360 degrees! Rational designers had less difficulty coming up with the wheel. The only advantage Evolution had is that until it managed to invent brains it was the only way complex objects could get built."


First of all, 360 degrees rotation is present in the flagella of the bacteria, invented about 3800 million years ago under intense comet bombardment.
Try to do it yourself in the same conditions ;). If there is no wheel in natural evolution is because legs are far superior.

And if you think that wheels are superior, NS invented it, because the inventor of the wheel was a product of natural selection. Even your feeling of superiority of the wheel and the very feeling of superiority of reason is a product of natural selection.  The claim of superiority of reason over nature is the last vestige of  unjustified anthropocentric in its most dangerous form: Pride and self worship.

And second, with more relaxed mood, I have to say, as I said many times here, that evolution works simultaneously with infinite variables and problems at the same time: log term and short term. Therefore we NEVER are sure of knowing in FULL the reasons behind an evolutionary design and therefore we can not understand FULLY an evolutionary design. That gives evolutionary design an appearance of mess poor design and so on. This is NOT the case. If evolution and reason collide, the prudent is to consider that the reason don´t know enough.
That is because Reason work to solve a single problem, Cognitive scientist say that  can handle no more than seven variables at the same time for a single problem.

THAT is the reason WHY the human designs are made of modules with discrete interfaces. No matter if we talk about architecture, computer science or social engineering, Each rational design module solves a single problem and communicate with other modules in discrete ways. This is what is considered "good designs" ,. BUT THESE RULES OF GOOD DESIGN ARE A CONSEQUENCE OF THE LIMITATIONS OF REASON.  Reason does not produce optimal solutions. it produce the optimal solution that he can handle without breaking. 

Natural selection takes the whole problem and produce the optimal solution without modular limitations. Starting from scratch, evolutionary algorithms have designed electronic circuits with a half or a third of components, that are more fast that the equivalent rational designs.  As Koza, for example has done:


These circuits designs are impossible to understand rationally. why? because they are not modular. There is no division of the problem in smaller problems. a transistor may be connected to more than one input or output and so on. But they are better, lighter  faster. it seems a "Bad" design but this is a subjective perception, as a consequence of our rational inherent limitations.

It is not a casual that genetic algorithms are used whenever  1) it is or very difficult to break a problem  in parts 2) is easy to measure how good a solution is.

 I have used genetic-evolutionary algorithms for deducing the location of extinction resources in a simulated fire. The algorithm deduced the optimal location every time. the only problem is that we did not know WHY this was the optimal solution.

In the same way, an human organ can perform 3 4 5 functionalities at the same time. the capillar tubes in a tree act as pumps, conducts, architectural sustaining foundation and may be many more that still we don´t know.

In the same way societies are subjects of evolution. A natural socio-biological institution, like the family has many functions, far more than the social engineers think. Its functions can not be extracted away by public institutions  ruled by social engineers without a failure of the whole society.

That is why conservatives rely on nature  where progressivists rely on reason and this is the reason why the latters fail miserably.

But natural evolution does not start from scratch it has to modify previous designs for new needs, while reason without the help of tradition  operates from scratch.  But this is not a drawback but an advantage for evolution, since the problems of the past may not happen in the present, but probably they will happen in the future. Evolution design not for today, but from all times to al times, taking into account past, present and probable future events.

Natural adaptation  exceeds  not only the capabilities of rational design  but also the rational understanding, as I have  demonstrated

viernes, 28 de septiembre de 2012

Kin, Kindness, and a stone-age Savior



About this article on two books, by Michael Shermer in the Wall Street Journal:


It is not about economy. It is about the foundations of economy and politics, and almost everything else. Shermer present two very different books at two different levels about the same topic: social bonds, collaboration, empathy, love, kindness etc. The first is focused in how closely the hormone oxitocine is related with collaboration. The second narrates the tortuous path that humans had to walk to evolve collaboration of non kin-related individuals, something that apparently goes against the odds of Natural Selection theory.

The second book has the explanation, the first, is the mechanism.  The oxitocin as many other hormones, are a mechanism that fix or promotes a set of behaviours instead of others. Hormonal discharge is the mechanism that the mammals have for modulating middle-long term responses. (For short term responses, they use electrical discharges in the nervous tissue). The discharged hormone flows trough the brain and adjust the responses of various mental modules. But this is a mechanism, not a magic substance that produces love, in the same way that the binary code is not a source of wisdom, even if it is used by computers.

The evolutionary explanation is the interesting one. Many people say that the switch to more collaborative behaviours in humans appeared around 50.000- 60.000 years ago, when the human population nearly dissapeared. By the way, the cheetah also  had an extreme episode of near-extinction whose result is that all cheetahs are almost equal genetically and very peaceful between them.  We humans also are extraordinarily similar and peaceful, in relative terms. Both cases may be related with  small survival spots surrounded by very challenging environments, that produced migrations and overpopulation of these spots. This is an environment that favour rapid genetic evolution. This produced harsh conflicts, but the communities that managed to make use of the knowledge and mutual help of wider group survived. May be that only one of them did, because this group was no more that 1000 individuals, according with genetic studies. Perhaps they survived thanks to a peaceful leader? A christ of the stone age that selected their followers from the peaceful ones? Was more like a Moses who guided the pepole to the promished spot in the middle of harsh conflict with smaller groups?. Was it otherwise?. In any case  My hypothesis is that Jesus Christ in evoked the instinctive feelings of unity and kin-relatedness selected in a small comunity 50.000 years ago from which we are descendant. 

The human empathy goes beyond doing good in expectancy of a return.  Humans may be almost pure altruistic. Many people sincerely die for causes that will give nothing for him (although it would give to their descendants, and this is enough for evolution to select pure altruism). However, pure altruism is not stable, But it is stable when there is a mechanism of collective altruistic, detection and punishment of free riders and aggressors. So the primitive leader, if existent, must have been a mix of Christ and Moses.

However the selfish tendencies are not maladaptations. They are more primitive, but they are part of our nature.and are decissive in how human society works. To be selfish with you is good if there is  loyalty (selflessness) around a wider whole that embrace you and me, and both you and me work for it. Selfishness inside selflessness make human society successful.

miércoles, 11 de abril de 2012

Why 90% of television advertising target women?




I love Top-Gear, but I don´t like cars particularly. Iike their jokes, Specially when Jeremy Clarkson exposes what is now known as prejudices. Some people don´t accept them even in the context of a comic show. This is a sign of this time when idiots and cowards rule the World.

To watch  this program I have to pay in the form of advertising. For me even have been astonishing how even men directed channels such are National Geographic or specially, Discovery Channel or the Energy channel in Spain have a great majority of femenine advertising.  May be because many men watch these channels together with his couple. But, the reason why advertisers spend more money in these women rather than  in their men, who are more motivated to watch these channels is something puzzling for me.

I know that femenine directed advertising has dominated TV from the beginning. Even when women where not "liberated" payed professionals, and women used to care for their famillies, there were a disproportionate amount of advertising about product for women in the home. There were a ridiculous amount of happy mothers advertising cleaning products. After the women´s liberation, this same 90% of femenine targetted advertising now promotes  magic beauty products, magic fat reduction products, magic healt products, dietary products for women and so on.

Why? Do women spend more time watching TV than men? I don´t thing so. Specially now, when women work out of home. The fact that in the nigh when working and non workin men and women are at home, the advertising is still mainly about products for women. Are women more monetary affuent than men? Neither were before nor they are now. Do women buy more spensive productos?  No . In fact it is the opposite: Men usually buy more expensive products. They buy the most spensive car they can afford, for example. Do women spend more money globally than men? I think it is not the case; In the old times, when  the marketeers counted the buyers in numbers of familly units, women had a considerable buying power, despite the fact that they did´n made money for themselves. Now women do, so the manufacturers create products for two different and completely separated universes of men and women. but I doubt that women have more money to spend than  men. Women buy things more often, but they buy cheaper things. Men buy less but they spend more in each buy.

If an advertiser would be what now is called "rational" -a form of simple minded stupidity economically sanctioned- and if the car business is three orders of magnitude greater than the dietary yoghurts industry then there would be 1000 spots of sport cars for each spot of magic yoghurt for weight loss. But the fact is almost the opposite.

The reason is that advertisers know that the money spend in femenine targetted products has far more returns and are more inmediate. Men are not so heavily influenced by advertising. Men are much more conservative. Introducing a new product for men is much much more difficult. That is what advertisers and market researchers know.

The reason behind lies in the different psichology of men and women, based in the different life that in the past, they had to cope with.

Frist of all, the Christian tradition of strong attachment of the young couple to the girl's family is a conquest of civilization. And it is the exception. In other societies, and specially in the more primitive ones,  the women abandon the clan of his parents and enters the clan of his husband. In tribal societies, the kidnapping os women it is the main motive of -and the cause of- wars. The alleged cause of the War of Troy is a symbol of the deep cause of most, if not all the ancient wars.  In any case, since the beginning of times, by agreement or by force, women abandoned their society and entered other that they did not know, sometimes they did not know at all.

So women had a problem. They had to adapt as fast as possible to an alien environment. The fastest way to adapt to a new society is trough fashion sensibility. Forced by circumnstances to live from the first moment in an alien society, without having time to know the rationale behind each cultural fact, the best way to be successful is to imitate the best practices around. "where you go, do what you see".  The best to do is to imitate the most sucessful women around.

As result of this adaptive pressure for millions of years, since prehuman times, the femenine psichology developped a much more stronger fashion sensibility and a shallow thinking.  Fashion sensibility is an unconscious, hardwired instinct, immune to education that produces aestetic sensations. Men are not absent of this instinct. The atractiveness of an sport car is a result of fashion sensibility in men. The same impulse makes this same sport car to look ugly and ordinary 10 years later.  Yet it makes the same car to look classy and exclusive after 50 years more. But in women, fashion sensibility  is the dominant way of thinking.

Men, who stayed for life in their home societies, where their descendants live for generations and very often died for, spend more in rational thinking because for men things were less uncertain. Prediction of future from what we observe in a predictable environment is the purpose for which rational thinking was made for. Participation  in social organization  and solving collectively problems with a mix of technical skills and innovative social organization had a high return of investment for men. Men invested much more in their societies for the same reason women invested much more on their children, just because these investments payed more for each one. Destroy the male role and you will destroy the society. Destroy the female role and the society will depopulate. both things happens today simultaneously, by the way.

So this is the reason for fashion sensibility in women and this is the reason of the higher payment of women-targetted advertising: An spot with a successful women who uses a new product will excite a powerful impulse in the watching women to buy the same.

Finally, to deactivate aggressive feminists, i would say that I'm sure that Intelligent women will agree with me. A sucessful woman said me so ;)